Wrapped in gaffa

Programming, Art, Music, Philosophy, Politics

Trash on portable devices

leave a comment »

Experienced users know that Ubuntu (Gnome) creates a trash folder on removable devices so they use Shift+Delete to permanently delete data. Rookie users don’t care that there is a folder and empties the trash can.

There is a bug report in Ubuntu that says Shouldn’t put .Trash-$USER on removable devices and there is a bugreport in Nautilus that says Ask to empty when unmounting media with items in trash. I think both titles are a sign that this is not a bug, but a matter of intuitive behaviour.

If we chose to have a concept of trash cans that is what we should stick with. Inconsistent behaviour is not user friendly. That said it might be convenient to have an option to always permanently delete files or automatically empty the trash can before unmount on certain devices.

I came across an actual bug when I was looking at the default behaviour. It seems like the trash applet is not updating when I delete something on a portable device. That should be be fixed.

Trash is rediscovered when the device is remounted, which is more than I expected when I read the bug reports.

Inconvenience #1
I can not empty individual trash folders. I have to empty all my trash.
Solution: Is obvious isn’t it?

Inconvenience #2
The folder is left on the device even when empty. If many different users use the same device. It would end up looking like this:
This happens on a FAT formatted device which lack a concept of users.
I could also imagine that some devices can’t handle directories prefixed with “.” and that is another good reason to delete the trash folder on portable devices when it is empty.
Solution: Trash folder on portable devices should be deleted when empty.

Feature #1
Option to empty trash before unmount with Yes/No dialog.

I don’t like permanent deletion as an option, when you can always delete with Shift+Delete or just enable the option in Nautilus and use the Right-click menu.

What is your thoughts?


Written by gaffa

2007-01-22 at 00:48

Posted in Gnome

Tagged with , , ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: